NIACC football all-Americans
2007
Lorenzo Brown (quarterback), honorable mention
2006
Anton Cullom (defensive back), first team
Ben Alford (quarterback), honorable mention
2004
Clint Sellers (linebacker), second team
Marshal Yanda (offensive line), honorable mention
2002
Robert Anderson (running back), first team
2000
Trivice Sadler (wide receiver), first team
1995
Corey Williams (running back), first team
1993
Antwon Kimbrough (running back), first team
1991
Stacy Jeter (wide receiver), first team
1972
Greg Steenblock (defensive line), honorable mention
1968
Bill Johanningmeier (offensive line), second team
1967
Tom Anderson (end), first team
1966
Reinhold Berg (tight end), honorable mention
1964
Jerry O'Donnell (running back), honorable mention
1963
Mike Heston (tight end), first team
1962
Jerry Dunbar (running back), honorable mention
1959
Val Mannens (Wigwam Wisemen Association of New Mexico all-American team)
1958
Pat Lennan (offensive tackle), first team